Technique or Feel (emotion) which do you prefer?

The place to talk about instruments, tab, the bands gear and anything else musically related.
User avatar
HoustonKJ
Lynch Mob
Posts: 5076
Joined: Tue Apr 26, 2005 9:24 am
Location: The Home Office in Olympia, Washington

Post by HoustonKJ »

dead forever wrote:
warhead dime wrote:
Jefferino wrote:Look at guitarists like Dime who didn't have a lick of training, but could write badass riffs and solos all day long...(obviously not to the technical "standard" as Satriani & others).
I've said this a million times, but it was quite obvious that Dime held back a LOT in his solos. And also, a lot of the things he did that go unnoticed to a lot of people actually take a lot of skill. For example, his fucking rediculous legato.

Listen closely to his solo/s in Shattered. He doubled the first solo and you can barely tell because he played it perfectly.
Also the solo in Throes of Rejection, the tapping run isnt simple, neither is the fast run at the end. Infact Id probably go as far as saying its his most technically challenging solo.
That is an AMAZING solo. :shock: I just listened to it with complete focus for the first time, thanks to your mention of it. My god he was inventive.

And you're right, Probably only about 1/10th of 1% of all guitar players on earth could nail that solo perfectly.
If you can't bench her, don't fuck her.
User avatar
Lord of This World
TittySprinkles
Posts: 11540
Joined: Fri Feb 11, 2005 9:04 pm
Location: Between your legs, erect.

Post by Lord of This World »

SRV hasn't been mentioned in this thread.

My favorite guitarists are ones that play with restraint.

David Gilmour - some of the best feel ever. Comfortably Numb, his most famous solo. Massive amounts of emotion but still clean and well played. the man's phrasing is one of a kind.

Ritchie Blackmore - a fucking monster on the guitar. why jimmy page is more revered than this guy is beyond me. blackmore's phrasing and use of odd harmonies are brilliant. listen to the hammer on run in Highway Star, it's more technical than it sounds.

Leslie West - not the fastest or most technical player around, but the dude can play the hell out of the guitar. he's written some fantastic riffs in his career. he's also a very good fingerstyle guitarist.

Robert Fripp - what the hell can i say about robert fripp.

Steve Howe - another technical monster, but the man has feel. listen to Mood For A Day, his classical guitar solo. perfect mix of both. his only fault was that he never played quite as cleanly as he could have, apparently he plays alot cleaner nowadays though
stoic wrote:good news...everyone took that at face value and immediately stopped thinking you're a scared dork fuck.
User avatar
The Fear
Obsessed
Posts: 32774
Joined: Wed Nov 02, 2005 2:45 pm
Location: Inside four walls

Re: Technique or Feel (emotion) which do you prefer?

Post by The Fear »

warhead dime wrote: But even though Petrucci has the ability that very few possess, he still can put out some great feel and tonal spontaneity. My favorite playing of his ever is off of Scenes From a Memory. There are a lot of slower ballady songs and his solos are fuckin tear jerkers bra :x
Finally, someone appreciates that Petrucci is not just a technical genius. :aargh:
down ass chic wrote:takes one to noone SLUT!
User avatar
warhead dime
Trendkiller
Posts: 965
Joined: Mon Feb 14, 2005 3:33 am

Post by warhead dime »

:pimp:






My favorite solos of his are the more slow ones. He has awesome phrasing and in that setting his feel really shines and resonates.
Wrona
Mouth For War
Posts: 3248
Joined: Fri Feb 11, 2005 7:37 pm

Post by Wrona »

Feel
User avatar
7Dime7MetalMassacre
I will fuck you up
Posts: 1728
Joined: Thu Jan 19, 2006 12:15 pm
Location: Where Earth Ends& Hell Begins

Post by 7Dime7MetalMassacre »

HoustonKJ wrote:
dead forever wrote:
warhead dime wrote:
Jefferino wrote:Look at guitarists like Dime who didn't have a lick of training, but could write badass riffs and solos all day long...(obviously not to the technical "standard" as Satriani & others).
I've said this a million times, but it was quite obvious that Dime held back a LOT in his solos. And also, a lot of the things he did that go unnoticed to a lot of people actually take a lot of skill. For example, his fucking rediculous legato.

Listen closely to his solo/s in Shattered. He doubled the first solo and you can barely tell because he played it perfectly.
Also the solo in Throes of Rejection, the tapping run isnt simple, neither is the fast run at the end. Infact Id probably go as far as saying its his most technically challenging solo.
That is an AMAZING solo. :shock: I just listened to it with complete focus for the first time, thanks to your mention of it. My god he was inventive.

And you're right, Probably only about 1/10th of 1% of all guitar players on earth could nail that solo perfectly.
THESE posts are fucking TRUER THAN ALL
Suck me
User avatar
earlp
Creampuff
Posts: 4
Joined: Wed Sep 06, 2006 12:07 pm

Post by earlp »

feel emotion all the way

technique is important but when you play with your own emotions you develop your own technique ad thats a good thing to me
User avatar
HoustonKJ
Lynch Mob
Posts: 5076
Joined: Tue Apr 26, 2005 9:24 am
Location: The Home Office in Olympia, Washington

Post by HoustonKJ »

7Dime7MetalMassacre wrote:
HoustonKJ wrote:
dead forever wrote:
warhead dime wrote:
Jefferino wrote:Look at guitarists like Dime who didn't have a lick of training, but could write badass riffs and solos all day long...(obviously not to the technical "standard" as Satriani & others).
I've said this a million times, but it was quite obvious that Dime held back a LOT in his solos. And also, a lot of the things he did that go unnoticed to a lot of people actually take a lot of skill. For example, his fucking rediculous legato.

Listen closely to his solo/s in Shattered. He doubled the first solo and you can barely tell because he played it perfectly.
Also the solo in Throes of Rejection, the tapping run isnt simple, neither is the fast run at the end. Infact Id probably go as far as saying its his most technically challenging solo.
That is an AMAZING solo. :shock: I just listened to it with complete focus for the first time, thanks to your mention of it. My god he was inventive.

And you're right, Probably only about 1/10th of 1% of all guitar players on earth could nail that solo perfectly.
THESE posts are fucking TRUER THAN ALL
Thank you
If you can't bench her, don't fuck her.
User avatar
The Fear
Obsessed
Posts: 32774
Joined: Wed Nov 02, 2005 2:45 pm
Location: Inside four walls

Post by The Fear »

HoustonKJ wrote:
7Dime7MetalMassacre wrote:
HoustonKJ wrote:
dead forever wrote:
warhead dime wrote:
Jefferino wrote:Look at guitarists like Dime who didn't have a lick of training, but could write badass riffs and solos all day long...(obviously not to the technical "standard" as Satriani & others).
I've said this a million times, but it was quite obvious that Dime held back a LOT in his solos. And also, a lot of the things he did that go unnoticed to a lot of people actually take a lot of skill. For example, his fucking rediculous legato.

Listen closely to his solo/s in Shattered. He doubled the first solo and you can barely tell because he played it perfectly.
Also the solo in Throes of Rejection, the tapping run isnt simple, neither is the fast run at the end. Infact Id probably go as far as saying its his most technically challenging solo.
That is an AMAZING solo. :shock: I just listened to it with complete focus for the first time, thanks to your mention of it. My god he was inventive.

And you're right, Probably only about 1/10th of 1% of all guitar players on earth could nail that solo perfectly.
THESE posts are fucking TRUER THAN ALL
Thank you
:aargh:
down ass chic wrote:takes one to noone SLUT!
SPRIGGSEY
Creampuff
Posts: 7
Joined: Mon Oct 23, 2006 12:50 am
Location: Australia
Contact:

Post by SPRIGGSEY »

Feel for sure. As long you can play something clean and whatever your playing works for the song. Screw all this guitar wankery shit thats coming out. People have forgotten how to write songs
DeathSion
Cowboy From Hell
Posts: 157
Joined: Wed Feb 16, 2005 11:39 pm

Post by DeathSion »

Both.

Jeff loomis.
Post Reply